We may earn a commission through product links on this page. But we only recommend stuff we love.

Into the A+ Advice Box #87: How Can You Get Comfortable Fantasizing About Other People?

Welcome to the 87th edition of Into the A+ Advice Box, in which we answer all the queer and lesbian advice questions from A+ members who submitted their queries into our A+ ask box! Here, we answer your questions in a space just for A+ members, safe from the general public. (No guarantees regarding your ex, however.) Here, the Autostraddle team’s doling out advice on everything from sex and relationships, to friend and family dynamics, career questions, style, and more! We do this column TWICE a month.

Every other A+ Advice box of the month is themed! In keeping with the vibes this summer, the next themed Advice box will be all about looking and feeling hot. Look out for that publishing in a couple weeks!

Then there are general Into the A+ Advice Boxes, like this one, where we take questions on practically any topic. You can send questions on any topic, at any time.

So, now, let’s dig in!!


Q1:

At the request of the letter writer, this question and its responses have been removed.

Q2:

Hello! Random ask, but do any folks here have tips for working through seasons of forgetfulness? I have a lot on my plate right now (2 small children! full time job! copious amounts of community organizing!) and I recently lost my phone, forgot my packed bags at home for a trip, left my kid’s bike somewhere, and forgot my apple ID login all in a span of 36 hours. It’s been slightly hellish and very stressful. Also, I learned I have to wait 27 DAYS to reset my apple password. Bahh!!!!

Some days I can handle all these pieces of my life gracefully and efficiently, and then other times it seems like my mind keeps tumbling out of my head. I’m planning on talking with my doc about tweaking my anxiety meds, and am also looking for any other tips y’all have. Thank you!!

A:

Heather: Oh, friend, I feel you! I have always been forgetful because I have ADHD, but Long Covid has made it so much worse! Luckily there are so many amazing strategies and tools at our disposal. The first thing I would recommend to you is the book How to Keep House While Drowning, which is written specifically for people who have these kinds of neuro-cognitive struggles. Not only is it a total game changer in terms of learning to be kind to yourself for not remembering everything; it is chock full of strategies for people like us who forget things. The second thing is: take advantage of technology that is made for this! Here’s a good list of ADHD apps. You can also just Google ADHD apps/strategies. Even search for them on TikTok, if you want. There’s so many helpful things out there on the internet. And then, finally, just try to keep things simple, don’t be afraid to write anything and everything down, and try to be gentle with yourself. It makes perfect sense you’re having this period of forgetfulness; it’s super common! You’ll figure out how to tackle it in a way that’s specific to your own needs! I believe in you!

Kayla: I go through these periods as well! It’s usually due to some underlying major source of stress that I’m not really acknowledging and working through. Like, there are always sort of the obvious stressful things happening in my life that are at the surface, but I find it’s not usually those sources that explain my sudden repeated forgetfulness but rather stress UNDER the stress (an example of this in case I’m not making sense would be work stress being at the surface but the deeper source of stress being having doubts about my career entirely). The forgetfulness isn’t immediately FIXED when I identify the underlying stress/anxiety/other intense emotion, but it does make it easier for me to come up with solutions that can see results long term.

Q3:

How long should I wait after a break up of a year long relationship to start seeing/hooking up with new people? I kind of want a hot girl summer but I’m worried that’s unhealthy, and I already miss my exes so much.

For context, I was the dumper, I’m devastated over the breakup, and I wanted an open relationship before this.

A:

Kayla: I don’t think there’s a set rule here! It sounds to me like you’re waiting just for the sake of waiting and not because you actually think you NEED to wait to start seeing other people. If you want a hot girl summer, that’s reason enough to try and get out there again. If it starts to feel bad, you can always reel it back in and chill as a single person again. It’s not a permanent choice.

Riese: Yeah! Have your hot girl summer! There’s no rules. There’s also no rule that you have to make “healthy” choices all the time, as long as you’re realistic about what the results of those choices might be (including the possibility of angst and pain) and as long as your state of being doesn’t harm anyone else.

Nico: I agree with my colleagues and think that the most important thing here is to be honest and upfront both with yourself and others about where you’re at! Riese pointed out that you are under no obligation to make “healthy” choices all the time — and I think that’s true. Also, who knows what’s healthy for you? You’re an individual, autonomous person and you can make the choice to have a hot girl summer if you want to.

Q4:

So. I’m 36. Trans femme, sapphic leaning. Borderline personality disorder, liver transplant, and severe migraines brought on by chronic fatigue.

I have not had a lot of luck with relationships, my longest being for twelve years caring for an ex. This was super toxic, one sided, and both soul and bank account draining.

After finally putting that behind me, any plans to start looking again were halted due to my health and the pandemic.

Then I met someone. They were briefly on the apps before retreating to Insta. We hit it off immediately. They were trying to deal with the end of a very long term relationship and a recent autism diagnosis, I was dealing with all of my stuff. We agreed to take it slow. We messaged for months, but they were constantly disappearing for days or weeks at a time. Plans to finally meet were cancelled and the only times they opened up were when they needed my advice or emotional support.

After a personally devastating May I confronted them about their constant absence and their use of me as a person only to vent to. They apologised, resolved to do better, and then disappeared for another week. I exploded. They blocked me on all platforms.

I’m back to square zero. I can see no opportunities to find a relationship especially as a trans disabled person who can’t leave the house and lives off a disability pension. I also live in the most isolated city in the world so its tiny dating pool is pretty much all I have. Someone suggested trying through online community, but I don’t know how. And I’m still hung up on the brief sign of hope that was this recent person.

I desperately need help

A:

Nico: Thank you so much for writing in. I just want to start by sending a ton of love your way. Okay, so, I know this is hard, but I think you should stop talking with this person. They aren’t treating you respectfully, and at least personally, I think it’s better to be alone than it is to be taken advantage of. And in fact, a fear of being alone can be something that makes us vulnerable to exploitation, emotionally, financially, labor-wise. It sounds like you’re certainly aware that you have a history of one-sided dynamics in relationships. If you aren’t already, I recommend therapy or group counseling if you can get it near you or virtually because, while I don’t know you or your situation and am not a therapist, I do know that sometimes we can unwittingly slip back into what’s comfortable to us in relationships. What’s comfortable is not always what’s good for us; what’s “comfortable” can also come from patterns that we become wired to repeat unless we actively break those. So, and I hope this isn’t patronizing, but if you haven’t already, besides therapy, I recommend doing research into codependence and unhealthy / uneven relationships and the breaking of those patterns. For starters, my therapist sent me this guy’s videos. He focuses mostly on how childhood trauma affects adults, and I think he’s pretty on point. When you start dating again, it will be important to come at it from a place of security in how you deserve to be treated in a relationship so that if someone starts to try to engage in this user behavior, you can walk away!

And again. Right now, this person you wrote in about is not treating you well! They don’t deserve your attention! Spend your energy on yourself! It might also be time to block them yourself, if that’s possible, so you aren’t as tempted to renew contact. I am so sorry you are going through this.

As far as building community online goes, that is certainly a thing you can start doing. It might be good to take small steps first and work on building up your online queer community in general. I’d try looking for the subreddit for your city, and maybe asking around about other local online groups you can look into. Similarly, there are plenty of queer and trans subreddits you can visit (those that are still up after the whole Reddit update situation) and post there and chat with folks online. I would love to hear some more suggestions for finding queers to talk to online in the comments, too!

Q5:

I’ve realized recently that I have a very anxious orientation towards the political work I’m trying to do. Every little mistake or disagreement we have stresses me out so much, and I feel a lot of internal pressure to be really involved so that things don’t go wrong. I know these patterns are unhealthy but I can’t seem to calm my anxiety. I don’t know of any resources for this from a politicized angle – any tips or resources I could look into?

A:

Nico: Hello! Your question is unfortunately a bit vague so apologies if any of the leaps I take are the wrong ones! I’m starting by assuming this is some kind of political community / organizing work that you’re doing as not paid work. So, I just want you to take a deep breath in and out and remember that this is lifelong work and that there will always be something to do — even if you need a break or a step back sometimes — and that you aren’t in it alone.

I do think, with regards to mistakes and disagreements, that there are probably some general resources that can help with that. Having difficulty with both mistakes and disagreements sounds like it could be related to discomfort with conflict as well as maybe some people pleasing tendencies (if everything is perfect then there’s no reason for conflict and also everyone will like us). I’m sorry if that’s off-base, but looking at whether these anxieties manifest elsewhere in your life might help you untangle their source outside of your political work so that you can work to untangle those feelings. And I do think the solution here is about feelings, not about whether or not people won’t make mistakes or avoid disagreements. Because there will be mistakes and there will be disagreements. Now and forever! The point is to keep going, to repair mistakes and work together as best as is possible, not to be perfect in the first place. I hope that gives you some permission to loosen your grip just a little bit, and to trust other people to drive themselves forward, to do their best, to be there just like you are.

Q6:

I’m on the asexual spectrum and don’t often have sexual fantasies about anyone specific. When I do, it feels disrespectful to that person, even though they wouldn’t even know and I wouldn’t behave inappropriately towards them in reality. Part of that is that the idea of anyone fantasising about me feels uncomfortable. I think most people think it’s fine to fantasise but how do I be ok with doing that?

A:

Nico: I think as long as it’s not obsessive / you don’t make it weird, it’s a perfectly normal thing to fantasize about someone else! It’s a thing that happens! It’s natural! I mean, if you haven’t ever read The Essential Dykes to Watch Out For wherein there is a panel in which Ginger fantasizes about Clarice. I don’t know why I’m mentioning it, it’s just always stuck with me because it was so normalized, and I think maybe when I first read it, that I had some guilt about the same thing, especially when it came to some internalizing of the predatory lesbian / queer stereotype. But it can actually be freeing and super healthy and helpful to let yourself fantasize and to explore your own desires safely and privately within your own head. I feel like it’s a truly slippery slope to start policing our own thoughts to the extent where we feel guilty for thinking about people we find attractive.

You also mention feeling uncomfortable about other people fantasizing about you. If another person were to fantasize about you, and as you say, not behave inappropriately toward you in reality or even tell you, would you think what they did was wrong? Is there a way to hold your discomfort and the fact that we are all weird, messy humans who think about each other in your hands at the same time? It might be helpful to really sit with, first, the discomfort you feel around other people thinking of you and try to sort through those feelings before you turn to feelings about your own fantasies. I think part of this, too, might just be from the general freakiness that is the knowledge that we have been perceived. It can feel weird to know that people think about you when you’re not around! But it is in fact just a part of life, being perceived, and I do think there are ways to rewire the anxiety and initial “ick” that can come about whenever we are faced with that reality by just reminding ourselves over and over that having other people think about us is normal. What’s not okay would, like, be someone making unsolicited advances or cultivating an obsession with you, but you didn’t mention either of those things being an issue. I’m sending you love and wishing you luck in exploring your feelings. I don’t know that you’ll ever get to a place of perfect comfort, but I also don’t know if that’s always the goal. The goal that I’m seeing is to coexist with other people while feeling as little unnecessary guilt as possible! We are not ever going to be politically pure and perfect, especially not when it comes to the thoughts inside of our heads. As Andrea Long Chu wrote “nothing good comes of forcing desire to conform to political principle. You could sooner give a cat a bath.”

Before you go! Autostraddle runs on the reader support of our AF+ Members. If this article meant something to you today — if it informed you or made you smile or feel seen, will you consider joining AF and supporting the people who make this queer media site possible?

Join AF+!

The Editors

The has written 146 articles for us.

18 Comments

  1. Q5: Sending support your way. It can be really tough to see opportunities for the work to be more successful / hit less pitfalls and feel like no one’s taking it as seriously or urgently as you are (I’m inferring here that that might be how you feel because I’ve felt similarly to what you wrote, too!).

    Gently, very gently, I think it’s important to see this as a moment where you have some very specific, personal work to do in order to support the movement in a way that’s aligned with your values. What I mean by that is, I had to walk a long tough emotional road to realize that when I was feeling that feeling of “why isn’t anyone else seeing this?!”, I was really centering myself and my need for individual action. And elders of the movement teach us that too much individualism is not only neutral, it’s actively harmful to movements that are trying to build and strengthen our potential for collective action.

    I think it’s important for you to direct your energy towards deeply considering why you care about the political causes you do – really connect to what’s underneath the underneath – and place your feelings of urgency into that context. If you value equity, truth, justice, safety and dignity for all people, etc, it’s important to understand that those things require us to move in concert and at the speed of trust and relationship with those we’re trying to build with. Urgent action can mean we unintentionally skip over important considerations, sometimes safety considerations, for those we’re taking action with. Imagining that this one particular battle we’re fighting is the be-all-and-end-all minimizes the work of generations before us AND our ability to not burn ourselves out when the movement NEEDS people to be in it for the long term. The fastest action is not always the right action.

    All of that is to say, maybe this is the moment to do some more reading and listening to elders (and by that I mean, folks who’ve been principled in the struggle before us, no matter how young or old). This is the moment to unpack internalized habits of white supremacy culture, to learn from Indigenous and Black activists and organizers who understand time in a different way.

    I don’t want to dismiss your feelings if you’re feeling anxious because working alongside people who are truly getting it wrong within the work – because that definitely happens, too. If that’s the case, you may need to take a step back and spend your time finding a different group of people with a different strategic approach who you can work alongside with less anxiety (frankly there is plenty of work happening in the name of the “movement” that’s really just about reinforcing existing structures of power – *cough* Democratic party *cough*). But I believe in you and you energy!

    At times like these I find it’s great to do some self-searching and self-study at the feet of leaders who recognize the long term nature of the fight.

    I’d like to 1000x cosign what Nico said – “this is lifelong work and there will always be something to do”.

    Good luck!

  2. Heather, thank you for your answer to Q1. I would be horrified to learn that someone I was married!!! to!!! saw this dilemma as ‘do I choose my spouse and our marriage or myself and my city’ rather than ‘how can I learn to accept and grieve a necessary move away from a place that feels like home as I relocate with my spouse who also has to leave against their will to live in a place where they can be safer’. But LW, bud, if that’s really your calculation, that’s information your wife deserves to have as she makes her own decisions.

    • I don’t think the person writing Q1 was saying this – I think Heather saw it as “choose your wife or your city”, which is her own negative interpretation of someone asking how to both make decisions and honor her wife. Pretty bad form to bash people looking for advice.

      • I think “bash” is a pretty strong negative interpretation of that response..! Good advice does not always mean endorsing the letter writer’s position. My reading of the letter picked up on the same things. I did not see ‘honor my wife’ as a strong priority. Honestly? As the genuinely committed spouse of a trans woman in a red state in 2023, the answer is that if you can go (i.e., don’t have other caretaking responsibilities or things that truly lock you into place) you do go, full stop. That is the decision that honors your wife. That doesn’t mean it’s not really fucking hard or sad or unfair to everyone involved, or that there’s not room for you to have feelings about it. But in my reading that’s not what this letter, as written, was about. As a trans person this was alarming to read and I’m glad the responders are gently but firmly pointing some things out.

        • the writer did say that her wife was her priority. It sounds more like she’s having trouble imagining how to take all of the changes in and how to leave. I think Heather published a condescending and ungenerous answer, when clearly someone is in distress and reasoning out how to go about living. I don’t think Heather needs to “endorse” the writer’s viewpoint, and I also don’t think she needs to unnecessarily read bad motivation and understanding into the question, which is what she did.

          • I don’t see anywhere in the letter where they say their wife is their priority. They say they love their wife, which I’m sure is true, but that’s the extent of it. They do very clearly say “I feel very torn. Ultimately, I don’t want to lose my partner, but I also don’t want to start over building a home in a different place.” I’m not sure how you got from those sentences to saying that Heather’s reading something into this that isn’t there. If the LW was really prioritizing their wife, they would’ve said that, and then asked the questions that you’re making up for them, no?

        • also yup, I’m the person who submitted the question – otherwise why would I be pleading for some understanding! I believed I did communicate that I ultimately love and want to be with my partner, and that I also don’t know how to fathom this situation, thus my open-ended question about how to make tough decisions that factor in both me and my partner. Saying I don’t want to leave is honest – I did not say I wouldn’t leave, or that I was choosing a city over my wife. Perhaps I didn’t write it well – I think you said it better than I did. However, I really wanted help navigating this and went to a place where I thought I’d get that help – Autostraddle of course! I’ve been really disheartened to see how much people would rather read only negativity into my question, rather than try to understand what I desperately would’ve liked help with. What have you added to my situation by tearing me down?

          • I see it’s now been removed and clearly the answer upset you but I read it before it was taken down and I just want to say I do agree with N above and with Heather’s advice that while you obviously love your wife it was not unequivocally clear in the letter that her safety was your priority over your comfort where you’ve lived for a long time. And maybe the reason for that is just because you were very stressed about this whole thing and wrote a letter that was not very careful!! But I think in this time of very intense transphobia it is perfectly reasonable and probably even called for to state VERY strongly the need to prioritize your wife’s safety as a trans woman and to call out that it wasn’t clear from your letter that this was your priority too. It’s understandably painful to read but some advice is necessary and painful. I hope that even though now removed (shame??) the feedback has helped you reflect on how you discuss the dilemma you’re in.

            And I in no way want to minimize the difficulty of leaving your home and community and friends – that is not easy and terribly difficult. Any immigrant narrative will also speak to that (though this doesn’t seem to involve immigration and is therefore categorically different). But still. The move is needed. How to process that? Perhaps look for others in the same position, it did sound like you had other people to talk to in a similar boat

            Personally I don’t think autostraddle should have removed it. Strong needed commentary that prioritizes trans people’s safety is incredibly important now, even if it hurt your feelings

  3. the writer did say that her wife was her priority. It sounds more like she’s having trouble imagining how to take all of the changes in and how to leave. I think Heather published a condescending and ungenerous answer, when clearly someone is in distress and reasoning out how to go about living. I don’t think Heather needs to “endorse” the writer’s viewpoint, and I also don’t think she needs to unnecessarily read bad motivation and understanding into the question, which is what she did.

    • Alchemille, above, wrote “Personally I don’t think autostraddle should have removed it. Strong needed commentary that prioritizes trans people’s safety is incredibly important now, even if it hurt [the letter writer’s] feelings.”

      I’m not able to respond to that comment in-thread but I want to say that I agree with it. Maybe this is general editorial policy (is this something you can speak to?) but I don’t remember ever seeing a letter removed in the past, and I can’t recall any other advice column I read ever 86ing an anonymous letter because the writer didn’t like the advice or the responses of the people who read it. I agree that what was deleted had value to readers that outweighed the writer’s emotional response to feeling misunderstood, both to cis readers who might need to hear those responses, and to trans readers who might need to hear that it is not too much to want and ask for these things in their relationships with cis friends and partners, which is really where I’m coming from. I think what was there should had been preserved, possibly with some sort of editor’s note if it really felt like action was warranted.

  4. Q6 was mine. Thank you Nico for your kindness in your response. You were spot on about feeling guilt and not wanting to feel like a predatory lesbian, and about feeling weird about perceived, which I hadn’t really thought about before. Lots to think about there. I’ve been thinking for ages that I should read Dykes To Watch Out For so apparently this is my sign to order a copy.

    Also thank you Heather for the How to Keep House While Drowning recommendation, that looks so helpful!

  5. For Q6: fwiw I’m aspec and also feel super uncomfortable at the idea of people having sexual fantasies about me, because I only feel sexual attraction for a tiny handful of people, and honestly if I had the ability to magically make no one else be sexually attracted to me I would absolutely do it. *shrug*

    That said, I know this is a squick. It’s an emotional response not a rational one. I understand there is nothing practically harmful about fantasies and people who do it aren’t “bad” in any sense. So I just don’t think about it. And I’d argue that’s fine. I don’t see any harm in actively pretending no one besides my spouse thinks of me sexually in any way. I could be right, and if I’m wrong and the other person falls into the “never say or do anything about it” camp I never need to know. *shrug*

    I think if you are having fantasies about people and feeling uncomfortable about it then hopefully Nico’s advice is helpful. But it’s also fine to fantasize about fictional characters or generic people or whatever works for you, so I don’t think you need to make yourself fantasize about specific “real” people for the sake of it being “normal,” if that makes sense. *shrug*

Contribute to the conversation...

Yay! You've decided to leave a comment. That's fantastic. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated by the guidelines laid out in our comment policy. Let's have a personal and meaningful conversation and thanks for stopping by!